Tourism, Foot Traffic, and the Hidden Cost of Litter in NYC

Written By Angus Jackson

By Angus Jackson

New York's role as international tourist hot spot creates vitality and revenue but also amplifies the garbage issue in ways that overwhelm the city's infrastructure and impact quality of life both within the city and among the visiting population. As the crowds multiply in the most populated neighborhoods, the trash swells likewise, baring deeper maintenance, cost, and perception issues.

In a recent survey of the Sanitation Foundation, one-third of New Yorkers admitted to having thrown trash on the street at least from time to time. The survey found that the Bronx and Queens had higher rates of self-admitted littering than the rest of the boroughs, and young men, along with tourists, were the most likely to admit to dumping tiny items on sidewalks where trash cans seemed to be inaccessible or inconvenient. That means high-traffic areas—typically areas with high levels of tourism—have to bear the additional blight of trash because people are coming through them in larger crowds.

Times Square, which sees hundreds of thousands of people per day, becomes especially challenging during major events. According to one report, the area generated roughly 90 tons of trash daily during peak pedestrian periods, and during New Year’s Eve alone large amounts of debris accumulate from celebrations and crowd gatherings. This immense generation pushes the city’s sanitation services to extremes, often stretching cleaning and collection resources.

Tourism also creates high expectations. Tourists insist on tidy public areas; when that expectation is shattered byDumpster bags spilling over in view, trash-clogged sidewalks, and filthy restrooms, it can damage the city's image and tourism economy. The "Understanding the Littering Policy in Manhattan" article highlights how garbage destroys aesthetics and affects local commerce that depends on strong pedestrian traffic and tourist satisfaction.

Also, public restroom inspections within the parks of NYC give a telling overview of the area where use pressure meets neglect and trash. Of 102 restroom facilities that were inspected, almost 40 percent had trash within them, and 30 percent had no trash can at all. Tourists who anticipate cleanliness get frustrated with the absence of simple disposal facilities.

The Sanitation Foundation's "Don't Do NYC Dirty" anti-litter initiative also demonstrates awareness of the ways tourism and street traffic build up to generate trash, most notably in places people are most proud of the city. The program employs street art, media, and neighborhood ambassadors to attempt to turn behaviors around.

Even infrastructure modifications demonstrate the impact that tourism usage patterns have on cleaning frequencies. High-visit areas tend to be serviced with more frequent basket service as well as additional pick-ups, yet the surge in quantity that tourism typically brings still overwhelms what was originally planned to service lower baseline levels. Based on city statistics, baskets serving commercial or high-traffic areas are serviced between three to five times per day, whereas mixed residential/commercial areas are serviced considerably less.

In addition to heavy traffic, certain neighborhoods in NYC are also prone to garbage buildup. The price is not cosmetic; it is economic (more services, additional receptacles), environmental (spewing trash into rivers or attracting rodents), as well as image issues (visitor satisfaction). Combatting garbage buildup in high-traffic neighborhoods will necessitate both enhanced planning as well as behavioral changes among both city inhabitants as well as tourists.

Sources used:

Angus Jackson
Previous

Containerization and Clean Streets: How NYC’s New Trash Bin Rules Are Shifting the Litter Landscape
Next

The Psychology of Litter: How Human Behavior Shapes the Cleanliness of Cities