Rats, Litter, and Inequality: How Waste Patterns Shape Pest Problems in NYC

Written By Angus Jackson

By Angus Jackson

In New York City, rats are not just a nuisance: they are inextricably linked with litter, neighborhood disparity, housing, and public infrastructure. The link between loose trash, dirty streets, and pest infestation shows how environmental health is as much a social justice issue as it is an issue of cleanliness.

A large survey of 43,542 rat sightings submitted to the NYC Department of Health reported that lower-education communities, older buildings, and higher vacancy rates had much higher reporting of rats. These results are geospatially focused in areas like northern Manhattan, the South Bronx, and sections of north-central Brooklyn. A similar study of more than 77,000 buildings in the Bronx and Manhattan found that rat infestation was strongly associated with building characteristics with large quantities of refuse: many dwelling units, public or open areas, many nearby restaurants, and closeness to subway lines or old buildings.

What ensures the connection between such structural characteristics and rodent issues is often the fact that refuse has not been contained properly, resulting in litter and stinky garbage being accessible. Where trash bags are abandoned on roads, or where residents fail to clear curb space and sidewalks, rats find food and shelter. The research discovers that waste management becomes better and street cleanliness becomes enhanced in the targeted zones as a direct intervention to decrease rat numbers.

Second, NYC's new container policies are the direct cause of ending rat problems. In Harlem's pilot container zone, after safe bins replaced trash bags in pilot zones, the city recorded a 60 percent reduction in rat sightings during those time periods compared to previous time periods in the same zones. This shows that policy efforts that restrict litter (by containing trash) are capable of revolutionizing public health results.

Unequally, the rat issue is spread around. There are more litter/trash issues and more rodent sightings in the high vacancy/high poverty areas. They are the same areas in which there is poorer sanitation infrastructure, fewer trash receptacles, and more buildings with poor containment. The research identifies social environment (education, resources) and built environment (density, infrastructure age, proximity to public space) as intersecting determinants.

Briefly, garbage and litter are not simply visually unattractive on streets; they form the basis for pest infestations that carry disease, stench, and habitability implications. New York City's policy of containerization is an effective method of controlling rats by minimizing loose rubbish and litter. Unless focused on low-resource communities, however, the advantages will be skewed. A clean city is also an equitable city.

Sources Used:

Angus Jackson
Previous

From Streets to Streams: How NYC Litter Travels Downriver
Next

Litter Baskets, Better Bins, and Urban Behavior: How Small Infrastructure Changes Can Lead to Big Cleanups